There was a time when The Hunger Games franchise was everything a great popcorn movie could be. Teenagers fighting for their lives, elaborate costumes and the extravagant decadence of a futuristic society, and behind all that there was something meaningful. Suzanne Collins’ novels and their adaptations offer a surprisingly effective commentary on totalitarianism, class divisions, and propaganda. With The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping, the franchise returns to familiar territory, but thankfully, there is still enough compelling storytelling, interesting characters and emotional depth to make another trip to Panem worthwhile. Taking place 25 years before Katniss volunteered as tribute, we find ourselves in the 50th Hunger Games. We still start in District 12, but the focus is on a younger Haymitch Abernathy, played by Joseph Zada.

This version of Haymitch is a young teen who exists before becoming the cynical, alcoholic mentor audiences came to know through Woody Harrelson’s portrayal. Haymitch finds himself selected alongside several other tributes, including Maysilee Donner, played by Mckenna Grace, Wyatt Callow, played by Ben Wang, and Louella, played by Molly McCann. Structurally, Sunrise on the Reaping follows a familiar formula. Tributes are selected, transported to the Capitol, introduced to the public, trained for the competition and eventually thrown into an arena where survival becomes the only objective; all the while, political intrigue and subterfuge happen behind the scenes.

While all of this is very familiar, this movie heaps on the drama and builds the emotional relationships that give the characters something to fight for, and plenty of opportunities to remind audiences just how cruel the Capitol can be. The entire film is a rollercoaster of savage cruelty and heartbreak. That heartbreak is what provides a solid foundation for Haymitch’s story. After this film he is cemented firmly as likely the absolutely most tragic characters in this film franchise. The real strength of Sunrise on the Reaping is not necessarily the competition itself, but watching the events that shape a character audiences have known for years. Haymitch has always been one of the more interesting personalities in the franchise, and seeing the person he was before years of trauma and disappointment changed him adds another layer to his character. There is something particularly effective about watching a younger Haymitch who still has hope, ambition and a willingness to stand up for what he believes in.I will admit I was not sure about Zada. His look and the hair styling really threw me off. However, he proved to be a strong choice for the role. His voice work attempting to mimic Harrelson’s unique way of speaking was rather good throughout the film. He still brings his own personality to the character while capturing enough of Haymitch’s intelligence, stubbornness and underlying frustration to make the performance believable. His performance helps establish the emotional foundation of the movie, through his relationship with Lenore Dove Baird, played by Whitney Peak. Lenore and Haymitch’s relationship forms the emotional center beyond the violence of the games.

Aside from Zada, there were some standouts that need mentioning. Grace’s performance as Maysilee was also stellar. She added some much needed grit and dimension into the cast and Jesse Plemons was phenomenal. Plemons took on a heavy burden replacing Philip Seymour Hoffman as Plutarch. Hoffman died in 2014. steps into the role of Plutarch Heavensbee. Other series character recasts include Elle Fanning portraying a younger Effie Trinket, which was a great switch. Fanning did a great job.Ralph Fiennes took on President Snow, and like Plemons, took on a huge task of replacing a deceased beloved actor in Donald Sutherland. Unlike Plemons, I don’t feel Fiennes was the correct choice. His stiff British demeanor was not a good replacement for Sutherland’s acting.There is certainly some enjoyment in seeing younger versions of familiar characters and discovering how they fit into the larger history of Panem. However, the movie occasionally leans a little too heavily into fan service. There are also several moments when Haymitch announces that he doesn’t drink, which essentially amounts to a wink at audiences who already know where his story is heading.

Fortunately, the film understands what makes the franchise entertaining. This series of films has rewarded the over-the-top performances, particularly when portraying the bizarre personalities and excessive lifestyles. Sunrise on the Reaping continues that tradition with Kieran Culkin and Glenn Close, who clearly understand the assignment. The actual Hunger Games competition is handled particularly well. Lawrence understands that the arena should feel dangerous, unpredictable and uncomfortable. The violence is often brutal, and there are moments when the film successfully captures the desperation of young people forced into an impossible situation. Although, the flippant among us might find some fo the deaths … not funny … but strangely cartoonish. Still, the competition remains an effective reminder of just how cruel the Capitol’s entertainment machine really is.

As a plot device, the games are something more than an excuse for action sequences. The original movies explored how governments manipulate populations, use propaganda to maintain control and turn human suffering into entertainment and audiences still got plenty of this. There just wasn’t the same urgency as in the earlier films, and that is likely due to director Francis Lawrence pushing characters’ hopelessness in the face of oppression. My biggest complaint comes during the ending. After Haymitch’s journey reaches its emotional conclusion, the film gives audiences a reunion scene featuring an older Haymitch alongside Katniss and Peeta. I understand the intention behind the moment. It is designed to connect the prequel directly to the original story and give longtime fans a nostalgic payoff. However, I found it unnecessary and somewhat distracting. The story had already established the emotional significance of Haymitch’s journey, and bringing Katniss and Peeta into the final moments felt like one last attempt at fan service. I would have preferred to see Haymitch alone, perhaps talking to himself or reflecting through an inner monologue. Allowing the character a quiet moment to process everything he had endured would have provided a more personal and emotionally satisfying conclusion. Sometimes a movie needs to trust its audience and allow a story to end without one more reminder of what came before.

Despite that minor frustration, The Hunger Games: Sunrise on the Reaping is an enjoyable addition to the franchise. It may not offer the same sense of discovery or thematic urgency as the original movies, but it succeeds in giving one of the franchise’s most recognizable characters a story worth telling. Haymitch’s transformation is tragic, and compelling. This film earns a solid 8/10.

By editor